Overview

Angelina’s Italian Deli, nestled in the heart of Newtown, CT, is a shining example of authentic Italian cuisine fused with genuine hospitality. This charming deli brings a slice of Arthur Avenue’s famed flavors to Connecticut, offering a relaxed yet vibrant atmosphere perfect for casual lunches, family gatherings, or catering elegant events.

The strength of Angelina’s lies in its dedication to quality and tradition. Their paninis, built on freshly baked Bronx-style breads like seeded hero rolls and ciabatta, showcase an impressive selection of Italian meats, cheeses, and house-roasted vegetables. Whether you choose the Sicilian Imported prosciutto layered with fresh mozzarella and baby arugula or the grilled Italian sausage panini, each bite is a harmonious balance of texture and flavor, elevated by drizzles of balsamic and Sicilian olive oil.

The deli’s antipasto offerings highlight their commitment to classic Italian craftsmanship, featuring house-made mozzarella, roasted peppers, and artichokes dressed delicately to complement each ingredient. The Nonna's Sicilian Rice Balls are a standout, embodying comforting, authentic flavors in a perfectly crispy exterior that pairs beautifully with the deli’s signature paninis.

The customer experience reflects the warmth of the Italian culture Angelina’s represents. Guests frequently applaud the staff’s attentive and personalized service, often guided by owner Angelina’s recommendations. From busy weekday lunches to catering for large family celebrations, the team ensures every detail is thoughtfully managed, resulting in both flavor and atmosphere that leave a lasting impression.

Angelina’s Italian Deli is ideal for those who crave genuine Italian flavors made from quality ingredients, combined with a community feel and exemplary service. Their ability to replicate the vibrant culinary spirit of New York’s iconic Italian neighborhoods while maintaining a cozy, Connecticut setting ensures they resonate deeply with locals and visitors seeking an authentic culinary experience.


Amenities & Services

Popular for
Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining
Offerings
Coffee
Comfort food
Food
Quick bite
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy

What Customers Say

Kat Miller
Dec 11,2025
5/5
For my sons birthday I placed an order for a full tray of marry me chicken, and half tray of penne alla vodka. It was more than enough food for 13 people, as I was able to send my family home with a to-go box. We all loved the food. It was fresh, delicious and even came with bread. I will be ordering from them for our future events and highly recommend Angelinas to friends and family.
T H
Dec 11,2025
5/5
Breaking out of my food coma to leave this place a review. I get why it’s packed all the time. I didn’t know what to order, and Angelina was so kind to offer some recommendations. We ordered the Mama Mia on a hero, rice balls, and Chicken Scarp. So delicious!
Kim DiDomizio
Dec 11,2025
5/5
Highly recommend Angelina’s Italian Deli and Catering! The sandwiches are amazing and the owners are so friendly! Forgot to take a pic of the Mama Mia yesterday which was piled high with a combo of quality Italian meats and so delicious. Today’s pictured sandwich is the Angelina, sooo good!! Get the seeded hero roll, the bread alone is fabulous. I can’t wait to try more items on the menu. It’s a MUST GO!
Theresa Viesto
Dec 11,2025
5/5
Food is always out of this world ! They put quality and care in each item they make. The whole staff no matter the time of day is always warm and welcoming. We also used them for a catered event which was a huge success, they helped set up in newtown with everything well organized. HIGHLY recommend for breakfast , lunch or your next catering event.
Josh Nickerson
Dec 11,2025
5/5
This place is awesome; service, food, atmosphere all A+. This is as close as you can get to Arthur Ave but, in Connecticut. The bread they use actually comes fresh from Arthur ave! Everything is delicious but, my favorite is the Rocko. It was a nice surprise to find out they sell the raw thin cut chicken cutlets breaded or unbreaded
Hannah Nohai
Dec 11,2025
5/5
Went for the first time today and will 100% be back. The deli was very clean and organized. Staff were super friendly I tried the Gabriella and the Angelina and both were fantastic. The portions were excellent and the mozzarella tasted fresh and homemade. Can’t wait to try more items on the menu. Definitely a go to place when looking for a sandwich and other menu items
Carly Brennan
Dec 11,2025
5/5
Probably the best chicken cutlet we have in town. A nice, juicy, thick piece of chicken cooked to perfection unlike other delis in town. Wonderful local family who is putting so much heart and soul into their food. Already can’t wait to come back and try another sandwich on their menu!! Photo is of the Kristyn

Leave a Review

Location

Opening Hours

Monday 06:00 AM - 04:00 PM
Tuesday 06:00 AM - 04:00 PM
Wednesday 06:00 AM - 04:00 PM
Thursday 06:00 AM - 04:00 PM
Friday 06:00 AM - 04:00 PM
Saturday 06:00 AM - 04:00 PM
Sunday Closed
Top Picks for You

More Italian Restaurants in Newtown, Connecticut, USA

Handpicked spots for food lovers. Your next favorite meal awaits!